What's the best indie compilation album?

21 October 2023, 17:00

From cult classics to the best of Britpop, the compilation can be a wonderful thing. But which one is the best?

By Radio X

@RadioX

Some people look down their nose at compilation albums but we think that when they get it right, there's nothing better about getting to enjoy a mixed bag of the best tracks by a bunch of different artists. So here's some of our favourites!

1. Shine

   

   Considered by some to be the definitive catalogue of Britpop’s biggest bands, the Shine compilations ran from 1995 to 1998. Placebo, Pulp, Charlatans and Supergrass were regular features. Classic banger: The Charlatans - Weirdo

   

   The Charlatans - Weirdo

2. Cigarettes And Alcohol

   

   Eye-catching covers suggested the kind of swaggering attitude these compilations aimed to capitalise on. Should I Stay Or Should I Go and A Town Called Malice set the tone and we can just about forgive them including Wheatus. Classic banger: Oasis - Cigarettes & Alcohol, of course!

   

   Oasis - Cigarettes & Alcohol (Official Video)

3. The Help Album

   

   In 1995, The Help Album was released just days after it was recorded and proved a huge hit and raised a stack of money for the War Child charity. The quality of tracks helped: a Manics cover of Raindrops Keep Fallin’ On My Head, an early outing for Radiohead’s Lucky and even Kate Moss offering backing vocals to Oasis. Classic banger: Weller, McCartney and Gallagher as The Smokin' Mojo Filters - Come Together

   

   Paul Weller / Smokin' Mojo Filters - Come Together

4. Now That’s What I Call Music

   

   It’s now dedicated to pop but in its earlier years, the Now compilation series tipped its hat to guitar music on plenty of occasions. The very first Now! featured The Cure and by the 1990s, The La’s, The Jesus And Mary Chain and Faith No More were appearing on discs. Classic banger on Now 17: Depeche Mode - Enjoy The Silence

   

   Depeche Mode - Enjoy The Silence (Official Video)

5. Modular Presents Leave Them All Behind

   

   In the 2000s, as dance and rock became harder to split, Australian record label Modular brought the two genres together. Bloc Party, Death From Above 1979 and The Rakes all featured in the two editions. Lazy DJs were known to just put this on repeat, it was that good. Classic banger: Bloc Party - Banquet (Phones Disco Edit)

   

   Bloc Party - Banquet (Phones Disco Edit)

6. Alternative 90s

   

   Spanning an entire decade’s rock output is never going to be easy, but this two-disc compilation made a good go of it. Ranging from The Prodigy to Jamiroquai via Dee-Lite and Pixies, it had something for everyone. Classic banger: The Prodigy - Charly

   

   The Prodigy - Charly (Original Mix)

7. Bez’s Madchester Anthems!

   

   What this compilation lacked in tasteful cover design, it more than made up for with actually great tunes. Sure, There She Goes and Panic by The Smiths might struggle to be classed as “Madchester” but Bez knows best. Classic banger: Happy Mondays - Step On

   

   Happy Mondays - Step On

8. Late Night Tales

   

   Chill out tracks chosen by some of the biggest names in music (Turin Brakes, Flaming Lips and Matt Helders from Arctic Monkeys) and dance (Fatboy Slim, Air and Four Tet). Especially worth a listen: Alex Turner’s story that closes out his buddy Matt’s selection. Classic Banger: The Rapture - Olio (from the Helders Late Night Tales)

   

   The Rapture - Olio

9. Unbelievable!

   

   Released in 2001 but paying tribute to the sound of rock and baggy tunes from the early 1990s, this was a great blast from the past. Morrissey, James and The Farm all featured. Classic Banger: EMF - Unbelievable (of course).

   

   EMF - Unbelievable (Official Music Video)

10. Rubiyat

    

    The Elektra label has a rich and storied history and to celebrate their 40th birthday, they had some of their newer acts in the 1990s cover some of their classic back catalogue. Hence we we got The Cure covering The Doors and Metallica covering Queen. Classic Banger: The Cure's take on Hello I Love You.

    

    The Cure - Hello i love you

11. Ruby Trax

    

    In 1992, the NME turned 40 and celebrated with great new bands covering No.1 hits. So Teenage Fanclub did Dylan, Blur covered Rod Stewart and best of all, Johnny Marr did the theme tune to The Good, The Bad and The Ugly. Classic Banger: Blur - Maggie May

    

    Blur Maggie May

12. Sorted!

    

    Looking for an exhaustive collection of the sound of baggy? Look no further: this Ministry of Sound mix opened with Step On before hitting on the likes of The Charlatans, Inspiral Carpets and The Farm. Classic Banger: Inspiral Carperts - Dragging Me Down

    

    Inspiral Carpets - Dragging Me Down

13. Acoustic

    

    The late-90s and mid-00s saw a huge rise in the popularity of singer-songwriters like David Gray, Beth Orton and Ed Harcourt. Chuck in groups like Coldplay, Travis and Stereophonics who were known to whip out a pared-back ballad or two and you had the recipe for Acoustic. Classic tracks from the likes of Nick Drake and Jeff Buckley helped make this a winning collection for chilled-out Sundays.

    

    David Gray - Babylon (Official Video)

14. Communion

    

    A simple title for this double vinyl from the excellent label, featuring Mumford and Sons, Jay Jay Pistolet and Johnny Flynn. Marcus Mumford even pops up to help out on the brilliant Stokes, William's Zion.

    

    Stokes, William - Zion [Bedroom Live]

15. C86

    

    A compilation that came bundled with the NME, C86’s jangle pop sound was so good it sparked a whole genre of music and helped give a huge boost to the independent music scene in the UK. The class of 1986 featured Primal Scream and The Wedding Present, plus the much-loved Half Man Half Biscuit. All that and it was free! Classic Banger: Primal Scream - Velocity Girl

    

    Primal Scream - Velocity Girl (Remastered) [Official Video]